Eleven things I've said about coffee over the years were pulled out word for word and sealed on a page, and I didn't open it until I sat down to answer them. Most of them still hold. A handful softened. One I'd take back, and the one I'd defend hardest is still standing: your palate gets the final say on your coffee.
The ones that still hold
I still pick burr over blade. I haven't messed with a blade grinder in years, and I'd still tell anyone starting out to get a burr grinder. You'll taste the difference fast.
I still stir a French press, and a Clever too. I don't think four minutes of sitting in the cup pulls enough out of the grounds. Stir it well and you can almost plunge right away, and you'll get a cup that's a little lighter and still plenty good. For pour over, I stopped stirring years ago. My cups were just as good and more consistent, and consistency is what I was after. If you'd like to play with agitation there, work on your pour technique, since a pour is a kind of stirring anyway.
Brazilian coffee. You really can't mess it up. I've roasted it fast and slow, and light, medium or dark, it works. Nutty, chocolatey, low acidity, great with creamer and lovely as a single origin espresso. I used to write it off, and it was the cheapest thing I could buy. Over the years I've come to love it. It can still get boring if it's all you drink, because it reminds me of a good diner cup, and after a while you'll want something more expressive.
I mostly still leave grind size alone. On my hand grinders with no numbers on them, I set it and change other things in the cup instead. On the ones with a dial I'll nudge it here and there, though less than you'd think. I'm a creature of habit.
The ones that softened
Metal filters. I've called them muddy and one dimensional, and I still mostly think that. The grinder is what's changing my mind. Grind a little faster on my ZP6, or turn the speed up on my Timemore, and I'm getting real clarity through a metal filter on a V60, and now and then on my AeroPress. And sometimes I don't want every bit filtered out. It's okay to let a coffee be what it is.
The refractometer. I once called a TDS meter the device we all need. I still think it's worth having, and your palate works fine without one. You spend $30 or $40 on a bag of coffee, a recipe doesn't work, and you go online frustrated. A refractometer gave me the confidence to sort that out on my own. It shows me what my pours and my other inputs are actually doing to the extraction, and then I check the number against what I taste. Mine cost $800 years ago. Some cost a couple hundred dollars and get you close. It's a way to see how extraction lines up with flavor, and then you adjust from there.
Brewer material matters a little, and I still wouldn't lose sleep over it. I have an Origami in plastic and in porcelain, and a porcelain Kalita Wave. The porcelain ones run hotter, though I don't preheat them over and over. I rinse the paper and brew. I still reach for plastic, because I'm not scared of dropping it. Get the brewer you'll actually use every day, and wash it by hand.
My old line on cleaning was every other day. These days I try to clean every day, and sometimes I forget. Every so often everything that's dishwasher safe goes in together, and I love seeing it all come out clean. And I always wash up before I film, because somebody would call me out.
Being done with grinders. I'm done with electric grinders, hopefully. Hand grinders, probably not. I'll likely pick up one or two more out of curiosity, to see how they stack up against the big ones. Most people I talk to have one or two hand grinders, and that's all they need. A K Ultra alone would cover you.
The one I'd take back
My old line that a 1:10 ratio would hurt you was too strong. It depends on the coffee. A Nicaraguan I had recently needed 1:10, and that's where it came alive. Some coffees ask for it. If it's too harsh for you, add a little water to that cup, or skip 1:10 next time. Taste it first and sip it for a while.
And think about the bag. A 12 ounce bag is 340 grams. At 10 grams a cup, that's 34 tries at one coffee. Even half a pound gives you about 22. That's a lot of chances, so try it.
My palate is still the final boss
The last rule was that your palate is the most important indicator, and I'd say it the same way today. A refractometer is great. Coffee still goes in your mouth, and if you taste something awesome, you taste something awesome.
That's something to be a little selfish about. Use someone's recipe if you want. Just keep your palate. When you trust a recipe completely and then get frustrated that you're not tasting what it promised, you've handed over the one tool that's yours. Guard it.
Brush your teeth, clean your tongue, whatever helps you taste the coffee. The smell can lie to you sometimes. Your palate is the last check.
What would yours say?
Eleven was a lot. If I do this again I'll keep it to five. And if I contradict myself along the way, that's because I'm human.
What's a rule you've told yourself about your coffee that you'd want read back to you?